seeking help determining referent of "dieselben" in a sentence
-
- Story Teller
- Beiträge: 270
- Registriert: 7. Nov 2016 14:44
- Muttersprache: English
seeking help determining referent of "dieselben" in a sentence
Not clear on the referent of "dieselben" below --
Wenn Se. Majestät darauf bestehen, das gesamte Heer nach dem Osten zu führen, so würden dieselben kein schlagfertiges Heer, sondern einen wüsten Haufen ungeordneter bewaffneter Menschen ohne Verpflegung haben.
My guess is that dieselben refers to "Heer" -- But then the sentence would say
"If his Majesty insists on leading the whole army to the East, then the same [the army] would have no battle-ready army, but a wild bunch of disordered, armed men without food."
Can the German language say, "the army would have no battle-ready army"? Can it use "haben" that way?
Thank you for any assistance.
-
- Lingo Whiz
- Beiträge: 2799
- Registriert: 13. Jun 2010 01:36
- Muttersprache: de, (pl)
Re: seeking help determining referent of "dieselben" in a sentence
It's a trap!
No, it's probably refering to "Se. Majestät" and a bit of old fashioned grammar that nobody uses anymore. I'm saying "probably" because this was used slightly differently in different regions of Germany, so I may be wrong.
No, it's probably refering to "Se. Majestät" and a bit of old fashioned grammar that nobody uses anymore. I'm saying "probably" because this was used slightly differently in different regions of Germany, so I may be wrong.
You're never too old to learn something stupid.
Mistake – Suggestion – You sure that's right?
Mistake – Suggestion – You sure that's right?
-
- Anglo Master
- Beiträge: 3671
- Registriert: 1. Okt 2009 14:25
- Muttersprache: Deutsch
Re: seeking help determining referent of "dieselben" in a sentence
Hi,
I think tiorthan is right, well, I'm actually sure he is and Wikipedia knows why:
"Darüber hinaus war es – insbesondere im offiziellen Schriftverkehr – üblich, die Pronomen er und sie in Bezug auf einen König/Kaiser bzw. eine Königin/Kaiserin zu vermeiden. Stattdessen wurden die Pronomen Allerhöchstdieselben bzw. Allerhöchstdieselbe verwendet."
Obviously, Moltke was very upset about Wilhelm's plan and dropped the "allerhöchst" in his fury...
Duckduck
I think tiorthan is right, well, I'm actually sure he is and Wikipedia knows why:
"Darüber hinaus war es – insbesondere im offiziellen Schriftverkehr – üblich, die Pronomen er und sie in Bezug auf einen König/Kaiser bzw. eine Königin/Kaiserin zu vermeiden. Stattdessen wurden die Pronomen Allerhöchstdieselben bzw. Allerhöchstdieselbe verwendet."
Obviously, Moltke was very upset about Wilhelm's plan and dropped the "allerhöchst" in his fury...
Duckduck

Mein Farbcode für Korrekturen:
Fehler / Stil/Ausdruck / Anmerkung
Fehler / Stil/Ausdruck / Anmerkung
-
- Story Teller
- Beiträge: 270
- Registriert: 7. Nov 2016 14:44
- Muttersprache: English
Re: seeking help determining referent of "dieselben" in a sentence
Thank you tiorthan and Duckduck! Wonderful help.