Hey everyone,
I have some problems with using the right tenses.
10. Do you like to have something to eat? No thank you I ... (just have) dinner.
I would fill "just had" in the gap but it says that it's wrong. Which tense would be right?
Which tense I have to use?
-
- Bilingual Newbie
- Beiträge: 3
- Registriert: 30. Mai 2012 13:45
- Muttersprache: German
-
- Lingo Whiz
- Beiträge: 2809
- Registriert: 13. Jun 2010 01:36
- Muttersprache: de, (pl)
Re: Which tense I have to use?
Which tense do I have to use?
The correct choice is "have just had" (Presen perfect).20millionmilestohope hat geschrieben: 10. Do you like to have something to eat? No thank you I ... (just have) dinner.
I would fill "just had" in the gap but it says that it's wrong. Which tense would be right?
Why? You're being asked whether you want somthing to eat? That's a question about the present. Your answer gives a reason why you don't want anything right now. The reason is a direct (that's why you use "just") result of some action you did in the past.
Since you're talking about now: The time is non-past (aka. present).
Since you're talking about a direct result of an action: The aspect is perfect.
= Present perfect.
You're never too old to learn something stupid.
Mistake – Suggestion – You sure that's right?
Mistake – Suggestion – You sure that's right?
-
- Bilingual Newbie
- Beiträge: 3
- Registriert: 30. Mai 2012 13:45
- Muttersprache: German
Re: Which tense I have to use?
Thank you for the explanation. I found the following sentence on an other website:
"When she went out to play, she ...
(do / already)
her homework."
"..., she had already done ..." is right, isnt it? But why "When she WENT out to play" and not "When she was going out to play"? I thought "When" is a signal word for Past Progressive?
"When she went out to play, she ...
(do / already)
her homework."
"..., she had already done ..." is right, isnt it? But why "When she WENT out to play" and not "When she was going out to play"? I thought "When" is a signal word for Past Progressive?
-
- Lingo Whiz
- Beiträge: 2809
- Registriert: 13. Jun 2010 01:36
- Muttersprache: de, (pl)
Re: Which tense I have to use?
Generally, a signal word is just a pointer to a possibility. It doesn't enforce anything. If you come across a signal word all you should do is think about whether the signalled grammatical feature is actually useful or necessary. (Some signal words actually enforce the related grammatical form, but most don't.)
The past progressive is a past with a progressive aspect (who'd though that). Progressive aspect means, that you are putting emphasize on the duration of the action. But emphasize on the duration is only necessary when things happen simultaneously or when there is a period of time involved or when the speaker wants to emphasize the duration. Neither applies here because "homework" and "go out to play" happen in sequence and when is used to identify a point in time in this sentence. I also see no point in emphasizing duration so consequently, a progressive is not necessary and you never use an unnecessary aspect.
The past progressive is a past with a progressive aspect (who'd though that). Progressive aspect means, that you are putting emphasize on the duration of the action. But emphasize on the duration is only necessary when things happen simultaneously or when there is a period of time involved or when the speaker wants to emphasize the duration. Neither applies here because "homework" and "go out to play" happen in sequence and when is used to identify a point in time in this sentence. I also see no point in emphasizing duration so consequently, a progressive is not necessary and you never use an unnecessary aspect.
You're never too old to learn something stupid.
Mistake – Suggestion – You sure that's right?
Mistake – Suggestion – You sure that's right?
-
- Bilingual Newbie
- Beiträge: 4
- Registriert: 18. Jun 2012 03:20
- Muttersprache: Englisch
Re: Which tense I have to use?
In American English, one would say "No thank you, I just had dinner." So you're right.20millionmilestohope hat geschrieben:Hey everyone,
I have some problems with using the right tenses. I found a website where I can practise using the right tenses
10. Do you like to have something to eat? No thank you I ... (just have) dinner.
I would fill "just had" in the gap but it says that it's wrong. Which tense would be right?
"When" is not a signifier of past progressive and "When she went out to play" is correct. This is just one example of when simple past is used. I think you may be confusing "when" with "while" because in German, you'd use "als", which can mean either.20millionmilestohope hat geschrieben:Thank you for the explanation. I found the following sentence on an other website:
"When she went out to play, she ...
(do / already)
her homework."
"..., she had already done ..." is right, isnt it? But why "When she WENT out to play" and not "When she was going out to play"? I thought "When" is a signal word for Past Progressive?